I made these little magic keys this years for the kiddos in my life without a chimney. I've seen these around, and when I saw these little skeleton key at the hardware store I thought-hey....I've got a plan for that.
You could use old keys to retired locks in your house, or buy these vintage-ish looking keys for just about a buck. I went with gold, though I could have sprayed it silver or rust.
I painted it with mod podge, then glittered. Once it dried I painted another layer of mod podge. It dries clear, but it helps the glitter adhere to the key and not flake off. I made this free printable I adapted from other poems I read. You can print that here.